The Danish language's irritable vowel syndrome
An overabundance of vowel sounds makes Danish a difficult language to learn even for Danish children, say linguists
A 15-month-old Croatian child understands approximately 150 words, while a Danish child of the same age understands just 84 on average.
ItÂs not because Danish kids are dumb, or because Croatian kids are geniuses. ItÂs because Danish has too many vowel sounds, says Dorthe Bleses, a linguist at the Center for Child Language at the University of Southern Denmark.
ÂThe number of vowels has big significance for how difficult it is to learn a language. Many vowels makes a difficult language,Â Bleses told Weekendavisen newspaper recently.
The official number of vowels in Danish is nine: a, e, i, o, u, Ã¦, Ã¸, Ã¥ and y.
ÂÂYÂ isnÂt a vowel,Â you say? Well, in Danish it is. In Danish, even consonants are vowels.
But written Danish is not the issue. The problems start when Danes speak. In spoken speech, Danish actually has some 40 vowel sounds, says Bleses, depending upon where the vowels are placed in words and sentence strings.
To make matters worse, modern Danes ÂswallowÂ lots of the remaining consonants that would create more audible definition, or annunciation, between words. Linguists call it ÂreductionÂ or ÂellisionÂ. It is how ÂprobablyÂ becomes ÂproblyÂ in American English. In Danish, it is how ÂspÃ¦ndendeÂbecomes Âspen-n?Â, and how a simple, little sentence like 'Det er det' becomes Âd?-?-d?Â.
While marvelling at Danish pronunciation is an amusing pastime for tourists, immigrants and other Scandinavians, the irony is that the pronunciation is terribly hard even for Danish children to learn.
Bleses researched how children in seven different cultures acquire their native languages. Of the seven Â Danish, Swedish, Dutch, French, American English, Croatian and Galician Â she found that Danish was the most difficult for children to learn.
She discovered that the number of vowel sounds in a language determine not only how many words a 15-month-old baby understands, but also the number of words a child is able to speak and use. Accordingly, the linguist contended, young Danish children have smaller vocabularies than children learning the other six languages.
The new education minister, Troels Lund Poulsen, is just one of many commentators who have recently said Danish kids are learning too little and too late in school.
News headlines in past months have bristled with stories about how Danish kids Â especially ones with Danish as a second language Â score too low on the Programme for International Student Assessment (Pisa) and graduate from compulsory school with insufficient reading skills.
Does the difficulty of the language have anything to do with how early children begin learning in school? Bleses thinks so.
ÂOf course itÂs important that the teacher knows these things in the earliest school grades and can explain the difficult connection between the sounds and the letters. For that reason the learning ability can take a little longer to develop,Â she told Weekendavisen.
ÂBut the difference between the Croatian child and the Danish child doesnÂt persist. Once the children have reached the third or fourth grade, the linguistic code has been cracked, and then other things have significance for whether the student learns well,Â she added.
In other words, according to the linguist, it takes Danish children with Danish parents until they are nine or ten years old Â in the third or fourth grade Â to Âcrack the codeÂ of the Danish language.