No evidence to support tighter borders

New revelations show that civil servants desperately tried to find evidence of an increase in cross-border crime – to no avail

April 11th, 2012 11:29 am| by admin
facebooktwittergoogle_pluspinterestmail

The former government did not have the evidence to support its claim that a rise in cross-border crime justified the installation of permanent custom controls along Danish borders, Jyllands-Posten newspaper reported today.

The revelation comes about after the newspaper was granted access to over 6,500 government emails relating to last year’s ‘border scandal’ that reveal how civil servants desperately attempted to find evidence for a supposed rise in cross-border crime.

The decision to install a permanent border control was made by the former Venstre and Konservative (VKO) government in May 2011 as a concession to their support party, the anti-immigration Dansk Folkeparti (DF), in exchange for DF's votes on early retirement reform.

As a justification, the government wrote in their border agreement that "in recent years there has been a marked rise in cross border crime,” and to fight it they need to implement tighter border controls.

The border controls caused outrage across Europe. Many, including the European Commission, questioned the legality of the move and placed the government under enormous pressure to provide documentation for an increase in cross-border crime.

But the emails in Jyllands-Posten’s possession seem to indicate that the government did not have any precise information how much crime was actually being committed in Denmark by foreign criminals not resident in the country.

The emails document how, as a response to increasing levels of international attention to the border controls, the Foreign Ministry applied pressure on both the Tax Ministry and the Justice Ministry.

In an email from the Foreign Ministry’s department of EU law, they demanded the two ministries provide more evidence for both the European Commission and the international media, who needed “a few more details than the mere statement that crime was rising”.

But evidence was thin on the ground. The Justice Ministry replied that their only evidence was a 63 percent increase in the number of eastern Europeans charged with crimes in Denmark since 2006. The number was deemed insufficient, however, as it did not differentiate between eastern Europeans residing in Denmark and those who had travelled to Denmark for the express purpose of committing a crime.

The number of eastern Europeans that had moved to Denmark had risen by 83 percent over the same period, more than the increase in crime committed by the group.

Throughout July, as customs agents began patrolling Danish borders under the gaze of the international media, the two ministries attempted to find evidence to support their claim that increased border control was necessary.

But their attempts were in vain, as the Foreign Ministry ruled the supposed evidence of increased crime levels to be insufficient. By September it no longer mattered, however, as the VKO government lost out to the current PM, Helle Thorning-Schmidt and the Socialdemokraterne, who promptly dismantled the border controls and consigning the ‘border scandal’ to the history books.

Boat with syrian refugees off the coast of Sicily. (Photo: Vito Manzari from Martina Franca)
This Week’s Editorial: Tricky law followed by a piece of cake
Integration is the name of the game. The refugees are here – or on their ...
Fairies, batmen and ninjas gathered to participate in the old Danish tradition of beating the barrel
Kids Corner: Faster prep might be needed for the annual kids shinding
Fastelavn on 7 February is extremely early this year – actually the earli...
Christianity's most revered warrior tends to be Archangel Michael (photo: Luca Giordano (1632–1705)
How Christianity portrayed Jesus as a warrior to woo the Vikings
Despite more than 80 percent of Danes associating themselves with the Evang...
Snowden's trip back to the US had been arranged (photo: Elena Polio)
Justice minister admits that rendition plane was sent for Snowden
The justice minister, Søren Pind, has admitted for the first time that Cop...
YouSee goes full digital on February 9 (photo: YouSee)
YouSee haemorrhaging customers
Due to steep prices and better streaming offers elsewhere, the TV and inter...
In the period between 1978 and 2010, some 104 transgender Danes were approved for a sex reassignment surgery by the Sexological Clinic at Rigshospital (photo: iStock)
Waiting for surgery puts transgender people in Denmark under extreme pressure
A study published in the scientific magazine Journal of Sexual Medicine has...