Soldier acquitted of misconduct over colleague’s death

After incriminating statements were withdrawn by witnesses, a platoon leader is acquitted of misconduct and causing his colleague’s death in Afghanistan

The death of 22-year-old constable Jacob Sten Lund Olsen last year in Afghanistan was not a result of serious misconduct by his 27-year-old platoon leader, Næstved court found yesterday.

But acquittal of the unnamed first lieutenant and platoon leader was not without controversy, however, after he, his company commander, and 17 other witnesses either changed the stories they first gave to military investigators following the death, or said they could not remember details that would incriminate him.

Outside the court house yesterday, Olsen’s mother, Jeannette Neumann, said she was disappointed over the lack of respect shown by the witnesses to the legal process.

“It is incredible that they have experienced this collective memory loss and deny the reports of their interviews," Neumann told journalists. "We have seen the backside of the military’s pretty medals. It’s a closed community where no one says anything. Answers like 'I don’t recall that', or, “I can’t remember' have been said repeatedly through the proceedings.”

Olsen was killed on September 3, 2011, by an improvised explosive device that went off within a building named Compound 91 near the town of Gereshk in Helmand Province.

Olsen was a member of Team 12, second division Bravo company based in Camp Viking, that had gone on a routine patrol. Following the explosion, which killed Olsen and injured four other soldiers, military investigators flew to Afghanistan to interview the soldier witnesses.

The platoon leader was subsequently charged with misconduct after the company commander allegedly told the investigators he had given a verbal order to the leader not to enter the building.

Compound 91 was a known Taliban refuge from which Danish soldiers had previously been attacked. The company commander said an attack on the building was being planned for a later date.

The prosecutor, Kristian Kirk Pedersen from the Military Prosecution Service, based his case against the platoon leader on witness statements collected by investigators indicating Olsen died because the leader disobeyed a direct order from his company commander.

But in court the company commander denied that he had given a verbal order. He said that he had instead given a written “statement of intent” and that the platoon leader acted against this.

Two other witness that had at first said they remember a verbal order being given said in court they had a hard time remembering exactly what instructions were given.

Further witnesses accused the prosecutor of putting words in their mouths. In turn, the prosecutor accused the witnesses of covering for the platoon leader after they later realised that their witness statements could be used to prosecute him.

After the acquittal, military prosecutor Pedersen said there was no case unless the company commander admitted that a verbal order had been given.

“What I understand to be central to the verdict, is the explanation from the company commander who disputed giving a verbal order,” Pedersen said. “I have never experienced a situation in which almost 20 witnesses all arrive in court and claim they have been fundamentally misunderstood.”

The Military Prosecution Service has faced criticism for increasing the number of charges it has brought against military officers. In an open letter this April, 53 officers accused the Ministry of Defence of using the service to wash their hands of responsibility of the unfortunate consequences of dangerous military actions.

The platoon leader’s defence lawyer, Torben Koch, also accused the Military Prosecution Service of being overzealous after he recently helped a major beat charges of dereliction of duty.

Military prosecutor Peter Rask dismissed the criticism, however.

“Annual reports show that we are in line with the ordinary prosecution service in terms of the percentage of acquittals,” he told Jyllands-Posten. “If we believe that a regulation has been broken and that we can prove it, we raise the charges in court. Unfortunately that’s our job and it’s not up for discussion.”

The Military Prosecution Service has two weeks to file an appeal.

  • Three new countries recognise Palestine as an independent state – Denmark holds back

    Three new countries recognise Palestine as an independent state – Denmark holds back

    Norway, Spain and Ireland have announced that they will formally recognise Palestine as a state. A furious Israel has recalled its envoys from Dublin, Oslo and Madrid for emergency consultations. Denmark says it will only recognise Palestine under a two-state solution.

  • Digitization is the secret ingredient in Chinese restaurateur’s growth adventure

    Digitization is the secret ingredient in Chinese restaurateur’s growth adventure

    Publisher Jesper Skeel and Korean BBQ restaurant chain owner Zen discuss the ups and downs of independent entrepreneurship and how to crack the Copenhagen market, from both an international and Danish perspective.

  • Pro-Palestinian demonstrations divide Copenhagen society

    Pro-Palestinian demonstrations divide Copenhagen society

    As popular protests of the Israeli offensive in Gaza erupt around the world and in the media, from university campuses to the streets of major cities, discord is escalating between demonstrators, the general public, authorities and politicians.

  • Huge fire at Novo Nordisk – building “cannot be saved”

    Huge fire at Novo Nordisk – building “cannot be saved”

    A fire broke out at a Novo Nordisk site in Bagsværd on Wednesday morning. There have been no casualties, but the fire is “extensive and spreading”, and Novo’s administrative building “cannot be saved” say emergency services.

  • Denmark leads 15 member states in call to outsource EU migration policy

    Denmark leads 15 member states in call to outsource EU migration policy

    Just one day after the EU finally landed its New Pact on Migration and Asylum following four years of tough negotiations, a group of 15 member states, led by Denmark, issued a joint call for greater efforts to outsource migration policy and  prevent migrants from arriving at EU borders in the first place.

  • How to lead Danes IV – Cultural Bypassing

    How to lead Danes IV – Cultural Bypassing

    Many of us Danes, despite being well-educated and well-travelled, often lack experience in navigating cultural differences at work. This can lead to ‘cultural bypassing’, where we believe we are at a level of enlightenment where we no longer are burdened by the risk of making cross-cultural mistakes. As their manager, you can help your Danish colleagues by acknowledging cultural differences in the workplace.