Editorial | Fighting on the side of history

Before raising the alarm over men volunteering to fight in Syria, those labelling them as traitors should have a look back at Danish history

Volunteering for war is a serious decision, not least when the country issuing the call to arms isn’t your own. Such decisions are all the more grave if those back home deem you to be fighting for the enemy.

 

Nevertheless, an estimated 45 Danes from a variety of backgrounds have made the fateful decision to join the fray in Syria. Commenting on the trend, Jakob Scharf, the chief of secret police service PET, said the development “was like nothing we have ever seen before”.

 

In fact, Scharf is wrong. The situation looks unmistakably like the situation Denmark saw between 1936 and 1939, when 500 Danes – organised primarily by the Communist Party – took part in the Spanish Civil War on the side of the Republicans against Franco’s pro-fascist forces.

 

If history is a lesson, Syria’s volunteers can expect rough treatment when they get home. The Spanish volunteers, after first being criminalised for their actions, later found themselves in history’s good graces, given that they, like the Danish Resistance, had combatted fascism.

 

Thanks to that turn of fate, the Spanish volunteers now have their own monument, prominently placed outside what is now the Museum of the Danish Resistance, in a park named after Winston Churchill. A more symbolic location would be harder to come by.

 

Fighting in another country’s war is serious business, particularly if you are hoping to return home able to practise the tools of the trade. Those who have gone off to war should have an eye kept on them when they return home, but according to journalists and others on the ground in Syria, most of the foreign volunteers are motivated less by ideology than a sense of adventure – precisely the same description that was made of the Spanish volunteers.

 

PET’s report and the ensuing media coverage were met with the predictable responses, not least from the right-wing, which fears that such volunteers would return to Denmark as terrorists. The message is clear: in political and security circles, fighting for Syrian liberation is the equivalent of proclaiming yourself a radical Islamist.

 

There’s no doubt these men will be influenced by their experiences in battle. Some may even come back as the Muslim agitators everyone is afraid of, and they should be dealt with accordingly – as were the two young men recently found guilty of receiving terrorist training in Somalia.

 

For most of these men, though, Syria is less a training camp than it is a cause. With the exception of a uniform and formal military training, what they are doing differs little from the actions of the Danish military in Iraq, Afghanistan and Libya. However, whether they too earn a monument for what they are doing is up to history to decide.




  • Gangs of Copenhagen

    Gangs of Copenhagen

    While Copenhagen is rated one of the safest cities in the world year after year, it is no stranger to organized crime, which often springs from highly professional syndicates operating from the shadows of the capital. These are the most important criminal groups active in the city

  • “The Danish underworld is now more tied to Scandinavia”

    “The Danish underworld is now more tied to Scandinavia”

    Carsten Norton is the author of several books about crime and gangs in Denmark, a journalist, and a crime specialist for Danish media such as TV 2 and Ekstra Bladet.

  • Right wing parties want nuclear power in Denmark

    Right wing parties want nuclear power in Denmark

    For 40 years, there has been a ban on nuclear power in Denmark. This may change after all right-wing parties in the Danish Parliament have expressed a desire to remove the ban.

  • Tunø: An island running out of time

    Tunø: An island running out of time

    The island of Tunø harbors a community of 74 adults and one child. There are no cars and only one connection to the rest of the world. Now, climate change threatens it

  • Cross-border moves on the rise in the Øresund region

    Cross-border moves on the rise in the Øresund region

    The number of relocations across the Øresund Region is rising. As highlighted by 2023 numbers, Sweden benefits from a growing interest, especially among younger generations.

  • In conversation with Conrad Molden: The man behind the mic

    In conversation with Conrad Molden: The man behind the mic

    He’s tickled our funny bone with countless wisecracks and clever wordplay, and in the process, made Denmark feel a little more personable to many expats. An international import himself, funny man Conrad Molden has successfully carved out a niche for himself on the Danish stand-up scene, but it’s taken a solid 13 years, much trial and error, and heaps of Danglish

Connect Club is your gateway to a vibrant programme of events and an international community in Denmark.