Expat to be deported from Denmark after 32 years in the country

Mary Stewart Burgher given four weeks to pack her bags by immigration services

You would think that spending 32 years and well over half of your life in a country would give you some pretty solid ground to stand on in terms of getting a residency permit.

But that’s not the case in Denmark, apparently.

US citizen Mary Stewart Burgher, 60, who has lived and worked in Denmark since 1985, found that out the hard way when she applied for a temporary work and residence permit in a process she believed would be a formality. The Danish immigration services, however, decided otherwise.

Burgher, a Houston native, worked for the WHO in Copenhagen for many years – and this is where things get complicated as due to exemptions afforded to international organisations like the UN and WHO, she would have been allowed to live and work here according to the terms of their special permit.

Before retiring in 2015, she was told by the immigration services that residing in Denmark for over three decades was not considered to be a “special reason” for gaining a permit.

“It’s hugely painful and frightening. Of course, I can return to America, but all my friends, [volunteer] work and my apartment are here in Copenhagen,” Burgher said.

“I’ve made Denmark my home, and I’ve lived most of my life in Denmark. My life is here. Moving back would be starting over from scratch. I can do it, but I don’t want to. The painful thing is that I am very fond of Denmark and my life here. I don’t want to say goodbye.”

READ MORE: If they don’t like my rules, let them eat cake, says Danish integration minister

No kids, no chance
It all started in 2015 when she applied for the permit in a process that was supposed to take three to six months. But 19 months later, on 10 March 2017, the immigration services wrote to inform her that her request had been denied and that she had four weeks to pack up and leave Denmark.

In the eight-page letter, the immigration services wrote that there were “no special reasons that support giving you a residence permit”.

She was also informed that it would have helped if she had children in Denmark. Apparently, because Burgher is childless, having a brother and sister in Houston held more weight than her three decades of life in Denmark.

“Apparently others have succeeded in obtaining a residence permit because they have children in Denmark, and I have been denied a residency permit because I don’t,” said Burgher.

“Isn’t it possible to have a strong connection with Denmark without a child?”

READ MORE: Exile over, Marius Youbi is all set to return to Denmark

Human rights violation
Understandably upset at the decision, Burgher turned to lawyer Poul Hauch Fenger in a bid to appeal the decision. Fenger contends that the decision by the immigration services constitutes a violation of the right to respect for private life under Article 8 of the European Convention of Human Rights.

“The concept of a right to a private life encompasses the importance of personal dignity and autonomy and the interaction a person has with others,” the law firm wrote.

“The European Court of Human Rights has incessantly expressed the view that private life also includes the effective enjoyment of a social life.”

Burgher has dedicated much of her spare time doing volunteer work in the name of charity, including at the American Women’s Club in Denmark.

Ultimately, timing may also not have been in Burgher’s favour considering Denmark’s toughening up of the immigration arena in recent years. But apparently she was informed that she couldn’t apply earlier.

A week after Burgher received her letter of denial, the immigration minister, Inger Støjberg, celebrated her first 50 more stringent laws passed as a minister with a big cake.

Meanwhile, unless her appeal is successful, Burgher will be enjoying her next birthday cake in Houston.




  • What do Danes do for “Vinterferie”?

    What do Danes do for “Vinterferie”?

    As tradition has it, many Danes take a week off for Vinterferie next week. Or the week after. It’s a bit confusing, especially since Christmas and New Year’s Holiday are not far away. What’s going on?

  • The educational options for internationals in Denmark

    The educational options for internationals in Denmark

    Denmark offers free public education, but private schools and universities for non-EU students require tuition. Language is a barrier, with international schools available for children and limited English-taught university programs. In 2024, Denmark expanded university seats for internationals and introduced an HF-international program in Aarhus.

  • Aarhus Gymnasium is launching Denmark’s first HF program for internationals

    Aarhus Gymnasium is launching Denmark’s first HF program for internationals

    Aarhus Gymnasium is launching Denmark’s first HF-international program in August, offering young adult internationals an alternative to IB programs with a focus on career-oriented education and Danish language learning. Unlike IB, it reduces academic pressure while providing access to vocational schools and professional bachelor’s degrees

  • Top Danish companies report strong financial performance

    Top Danish companies report strong financial performance

    Some of Denmark’s leading companies reported solid financial results for 2024, with Lundbeck, Demant, and Vestas seeing growth, while Pandora tackled rising production costs with price increases and cost-saving measures.

  • Greenland restricts foreign property purchases and election donations

    Greenland restricts foreign property purchases and election donations

    These days, the Greenlandic institutions are approving two new norms to restrict, reduce, or ban the possibility for foreign citizens to buy real estate on the island, as well as for political parties to receive large amounts of money from foreign donors.

  • “The retention of international labor is one of the biggest problems,” EY’s director says on integration 

    “The retention of international labor is one of the biggest problems,” EY’s director says on integration 

    In the interest of both native companies and international workers, Ernst & Young (EY) Head of Immigration Rikke Gahrn Wolfsen recommends a change within the Danish integration culture. “The retention of international labor is one of the biggest problems we’re facing at the moment,” she says.